| Film
of the Week: 'The
Last Samurai'
By Steve Sailer
UPI National Correspondent
Published 12/4/2003 1:45 PM
LOS ANGELES, Dec. 4 (UPI) -- Perhaps
the most memorable character created by Edward Zwick and Marshall
Herskovitz for that quintessential 80s' television show "thirtysomething"
was the "samurai advertising man" Miles Drentell, a
sinister executive who justified each new swindle with parables
drawn from the martial moralists of Japan
Drentell
proved less satiric than prophetic. Two-thirds of a century after
the Rape of Nanking, these feudal philosophies of violence occupy
a revered place in American media culture. Now, Zwick is back
(with script assistance from Herskovitz), directing Tom Cruise as
an American cavalry captain hired in 1876 to train Japanese
peasant soldiers to put down a samurai rebellion, but who instead
learns to admire the old-fashioned "way of the warrior."
The "The Last Samurai" is a lovely looking but
staggeringly reactionary $100 million elegy for the good old days
when an insulted aristocrat could restore his honor by
decapitating an insolent commoner on the spot.
This
is the fifth military movie Zwick has made. He obviously loves
war, but his liberal conscience requires him to inject into each
film some multiculturalist moralizing. His first and best war
flick, "Glory," was a deserved tribute to the black
soldiers who fought in the Civil War. Unfortunately, his
subsequent efforts, such as "Courage Under Fire" (about
a ferocious Desert Storm chopper pilot played by, of all people,
Meg Ryan), have been silly.
Zwick's
spin machine faces its greatest challenge in "The Last
Samurai" because it's essentially an ode to Japanese
militarism. Rather than just revel in the cruelty of the samurai
tradition, like Quentin Tarantino does in "Kill Bill,"
Zwick tries to justify his fascination with superb swords hacking
human flesh by concocting a clever rationalization for why the
Meiji Emperor's destruction of the samurai was America's fault.
Yet, as David St. Hubbins pointed out in "Spinal Tap,"
there's such a fine line between clever and stupid.
The
samurai paralleled Europe's knights, but while the latter were
rendered militarily obsolete in the 15th Century by hoi polloi
with armor-piercing longbows and guns, Japan's hereditary
swordsmen used gun control laws to maintain their bullyboy status
into the 1870s.
"The
Last Samurai" is a highly romanticized version of the Satsuma
revolt under Takamori Saigo, a general who had helped bring the
Meiji Restoration reformers to power in 1868, but who resigned as
commander of the Imperial Guard in 1873 when his colleagues
rejected his plan to invade Korea.
Increasingly,
the young samurai advising the Emperor realized that to modernize
Japan enough to prevent its conquest by a European power, they
would have to eliminate the parasitical privileges of their own
class. Other samurai were less forward-looking. Deprived of their
traditional welfare payments and ordered to stop wearing their
swords, they rebelled and made Saigo their warlord.
The
new national army of peasants shredded their historic oppressors.
Defeated, Saigo committed seppuku. The Emperor pardoned him
posthumously, though, and his foolhardy valor became an
inspiration to the Shinto adventurers who attacked Pearl Harbor.
So,
how does Zwick put a progressive paintjob on such medieval
material? He has Cruise play an alcoholic, almost suicidal veteran
suffering post-traumatic stress disorder from witnessing a
massacre of Blackfoot Indians ordered by his criminal colonel.
This genocidal officer is hired by an equally evil Japanese
capitalist (who is in cahoots with the amoral American ambassador)
because he's expert at fighting "savages."
Get
it? Zwick's brainstorm is to portray the samurai as victims of
racial prejudice! See, the Meiji modernizers think of the samurai
rebels as savages, just as their American puppetmasters think of
the Plains Indians as savages. In reality, Saigo resembled Sitting
Bull infinitely less than he resembled Jefferson Davis. And the
U.S.had almost zero influence inside the Japanese government at
the time.
Cruise
does his best to whip these lackeys into soldiers, but when the
samurai charge, the cowardly knaves flee, and our hero is
captured. From there, "The Last Samurai" turns into an
Eastern "Dances With Wolves." Cruise is held prisoner
for the winter in an exquisite mountain village where the samurai
spend their days perfecting their swordplay (and the unsightly
peasants who keep these lords fed stay respectfully offscreen).
As
he masters the martial arts, Cruise finds therapy for his guilt
over the Indians in a profound friendship with the rebel leader
(who bears a distracting likeness to Yul Brynner in "The King
and I"). Together, they resolve to die nobly, banzai-charging
side by side into the American Gatling guns.
Cruise
gives a pompous performance in the throes of Oscar-fever. Still,
"The Last Samurai" accurately if distastefully depicts
the primary emotional characteristic of Japanese militarism: male
hysteria. |